Working with Facebook, I'd be pretty happy to have 100 comments or likes a day on a site. Heck, 100 a week would be seriously cool.
I 'like' a page that managed to rack up 12,000 likes on one of their updates in 12 minutes! 1,000 likes a minute. Seriously!
HOW THE HECK DID THEY MANAGE THAT???
Well, first, the Facebook page is for a very popular show that just had a pretty intense season finale, so they are riding a good high anyways, but it's not just about popularity. Coca-cola is pretty popular, but they usually have a few hundred likes or comments at a time. Big Bang Theory, a show that is very popular in social media can also hit 12,000 likes, but even then only has a few hundred comments on a post.
I'm talking about the
Walking Dead - whose stats are pretty amazing. It's a show that has just finished its second season and only has 7+ million likes (as opposed to 20+ million for BBT and 40+million for Coca-Cola) but can reach 40,000 comments on a single post?
It certainly helps to have a popular product or show, but that won't guarantee a good social media site.
The secret is CONTENT.
Let's look at
Coca-Cola's Facebook page:
Now they do have regular posts - 1 or 2 a day, it looks like, but they aren't much to look at. Nothing particularly engaging. No questions that will bring out the masses. No though provoking comments. Nothing that really bonds fans to their page. I might like Coke because.. I like Coke.. But I don't have any urge to talk about coke and they aren't giving me any reason to.
We see a great public relations page, here. Fantastic way of saying 'Look! We're involved in the community and we're talking about our product!' And that's great, but I can go to Coca-cola's website for that info. There really isn't a lot of 'social' in this social media. I'm listening to them tell me about themselves.
What about
Big Bang Theory?
We're certainly getting more content - and the number of likes and comments shows that. They are continually posting full episodes, clips, pics from episodes and even a few bonus items, such as scripts or interviews with cast or creators. Definitely getting there. But I see a lot of 'Check out this clip' 'Remember this scene?' 'We love it when...'
Know what that is??? PUSH ADVERTISING. They are pushing out clips, pics, episodes. No interaction beyond making it polite to say 'Watch this NOW!' I see attempts to drive to the webpage and to buy into a product, but no real interaction of the product. I don't feel like I'm part of the story or that I'm really even needed. I like that I can find info, so I absolutely do go to their page (usually when my wife and I are trying to remember if there is a new episode on) but not just to hang out with other fans.
Both of these are great for public relations - they show their product and have great looking pages. Fantastic way to push info out, but they aren't using Social Media. For the most part those pages are just plain 'media.'
Now onto
Walking Dead:

As you can see from this pic, they are certainly getting interaction. In the first 6 or so posts I'm looking at right now are pure interaction. We've got a great picture from the last episode. No comment about the shot from the Page - Just asking their fans to post their own caption. It's a great picture and from an amazing (I loved the scene) part of the show, so there is no need to talk it up, they just put it out there and let their fans tell THEM about it. I see an interview where one of the creators of the show answers FANS questions. Maybe not my questions, personally, but definitely from people like me. We see notices for live twitter events where we are, again, asked to participate.
Twitter.. hmm. That brings up an interesting point. It's not Facebook. In fact, that is a key to these results. We're not focused on Facebook - We're focused on Social Media where Facebook is just one part of the entire plan. We're shown blogs, twitter events, live chats during the show. Heck, we even get to PARTICIPATE on a
live TV show after the Walking Dead airs! All these things are designed to draw in participants. We're not just an audience - We're part of the event!
We are part of the event.
WE ARE PART OF THE EVENT.
That's the difference. It's not JUST CONTENT. It's the interaction of content. With 1/3rd the amount of fans, The Walking Dead can easily get 5 times the amounts of likes and comments on their Facebook as some other Pages. That's startling numbers!
And this is comparing a show that is in it's 6th season with one in its 2nd. Think those numbers are going to go up in 4 more years?
In the end, does it matter? Probably not in these cases. All three of the examples I'm using are pretty solid products. And all three have numbers that I would be ecstatic to even have 1% of on my pages. What does matter is the lesson we can take away from the crew over at
AMC - Don't attempt to create a page and just push information to your audience - instead build an experience.
Create a plan to build the social media experience. Interact with your fans in new and interesting ways. Think outside the box. Build a following that WANTS to go to your page every day to see what new treats you have.
Social media is an amazing tool, but just like any tool out there, it has to be used correctly and in accordance to a plan. A really nice hammer does you no good if all you have are screws. And Facebook isn't nearly effective when you use Push-Advertising instead of Exchange-Advertising.
What do you want to accomplish with Social Media? How can it help your audience? What else, besides Facebook, can you use to create your brand and the need for that brand?
Don't just build a page - build an experience!